He was only six years old when he disappeared from the front yard of his home in Pine Tree Hollow, which is around 5 miles outside of Hindman, Kentucky.
February 13, 1982: School in Knott County had been canceled that day due to heavy snowfall that the area had received the day before. Kelly being a normal child, wanted to go play in the snow. Despite his mother telling him no repeatedly, he eventually wore her down. She made sure he put on his boots, and then zipped up his coat before he headed outside. The following is as close to a timeline as we can deduce at the moment:
11:00 AM: Kelly went outside to play in the snow. His mom, Judy, told him not to leave the front yard.
4:00 PM: Judy checked on Kelly before she walked across the road to use her neighbors’ phone. When she returned, Kelly was gone. (She thought he’d went to a friends house to watch television.)
6:00 PM: Judy had prepared dinner and called for him to come back inside, but he didn’t respond. She ate, then went to get Kelly from the residence that she had assumed he had been at. However, they said that they hadn’t seen Kelly at all that day.
That’s when Judy went to her boyfriend’s grandmothers house and asked to use the phone. They said no. For some reason, they wouldn’t allow her to use the phone until after midnight. (I’m going to assume this was because back in the 80’s long-distance calls were free after a certain time..still though, makes no sense that she’d just say ‘ok’ and not push the issue or go to someone else’s house to use the phone.)
She did call the police once she was allowed to make a call, but that was around six hours AFTER Judy realized Kelly was missing. Speaking for myself, this is one of the most perplexing, and frustrating points of this case. Why would someone, that presumably knew Kelly (since Judy was, after all, dating her grandson) not allow his mother to call the police and tell them he was missing? I mean it’s early February and it’s frigid and snowing outside…Then again, on the flip side, why didn’t she just go to another neighbors house to use the phone?
Family members and neighbors began searching for Kelly as soon as they got wind of what was going on.
The official police search didn’t begin until dawn the following day. Over the next few weeks, police searched in water wells, creeks, the nearby abandoned mines, they even checked under porches and in sheds and storage buildings.
A Grand Jury investigation was brought up and took a look at Judy, Kelly’s mother, but was unable to find sufficient evidence suggesting she’d done anything to him.
At one point, Judy’s own sister had told law enforcement that Judy had killed Kelly and she had helped her do it… Obviously, this was never proven.
Something else to note here; Kelly did have siblings. However, Judy’s parents had custody of them because Judy suffered from epilepsy and struggled to take care of them all.
In 2010, Kelly’s aunt passed away. I’m not sure if this is the same aunt that had earlier implicated herself and Judy in Kelly’s murder. She had told Kelly’s sister that she would be leaving behind a letter, implying heavily that it would contain information about Kelly. I haven’t heard anything else about this letter, so I’m going to go out on a limb and say either it didn’t exist, or it didn’t pertain to Kelly’s disappearance.
When you search for Pine Tree Hollow on google maps, you can see that this is a small road, a small community. According to Judy, a neighbor told her that a green car was in the area. That being said, it’s never been confirmed by LE. So, why didn’t the neighbor tell this to the police? It just makes one wonder about the factuality of the statement…
I’ve also noticed that in differing articles, Judy says that the neighbor that Kelly went to play with either a.) hadn’t seen him at all or b.) told her she sent him home when it started snowing again. All of these contradictory articles are located on Porchlight Internation, which I’ve linked at the bottom of the page. I can’t figure out why she would say different things to different news sources unless I want to start being accusatory. I don’t really want to be.
Also, was Judy the only one home at the time of his disappearance? I know she had a live-in boyfriend, named Curt Campbell. The information available is extremely limited since the local news doesn’t seem to archive any of their stories. All I can seem to find is statements from Judy, where she says other people told her this or that… But I can’t find where any of those people were ever actually questioned by the police. It’s easy to go around saying “so and so told me this”… if that’s true, why didn’t they go talk to the police about it? I did manage to locate the email addresses of two separate individuals claiming to be Kelly’s cousins. I sent emails to both.. I also emailed the detective assigned to Kelly’s disappearance. Of course, none of them replied. I didn’t have any better luck reaching out to the Help Find Kelly Facebook page either…
I know that Judy accused Kelly’s father, Bobby of taking Kelly but he was apparently cleared as a suspect. I haven’t seen his name mentioned anywhere as being a person of interest. This is another topic that I’ve seen contradictory information about. One article claimed that Bobby was living at the home of Judy’s parents in Breathitt County, Ky at the time of Kelly’s disappearance and another article claimed he was living in Madison County, Ky at the time. There were also rumors that Kelly had been kidnapped and taken to Florida, along with a few reported sightings. Per Judy, one of his school teachers had told her at one point that a school district in Florida had called and requested his school and medical records. Unfortunately, a fire has since destroyed most of the schools’ records, so none of this information could be verified. I have trouble with this, because why would they tell Judy but not call the police? There have been a few reported sightings in Florida, but nothing was ever considered to be credible. I’m not even sure who would have taken him to Florida, since his father was living in Kentucky at the time of his disappearance, and remained there until his death.
There was an article/video released in 2018 regarding Kelly’s disappearance by WHAS11. They keep saying that he vanished from Hazard, which is in a completely different county than Mousie/Larkslane.
Sometime in the late ’90s, a tip came in urging police to look under a concrete porch that was poured at the home where he went missing from. I’m not sure of the date, none of the news articles I found that mentioned gave an exact time.
After that, the last tip came into KSP in 2013. They were provided with a possible location where Kelly’s remains were rumored to have been buried, again, back on Pine Tree Hollow. After days of excavations and search efforts, they were unable to find any indication that it had ever been Kelly’s burial location.
All in all, this case just get more and more confusing the deeper you dig. In part because so many of the articles tell differing versions of events. This could be because the person they’re interviewing keeps changing their story, but it’s very frustrating to sort through. I can only imagine how LE must feel about it. Over the lifespan of this case, there has only been one person of interest mentioned: Judy Moore. Now, I’m not saying that I think she killed Kelly, but I do think there’s more than meets the eye to this story.
I would like to know if anyone else actually saw Kelly on the day he was reported missing, and when I say that, I mean actual verifiable eye witness sightings. Not people that Judy is saying she talked to that claimed to have seen him.
Was there anyone else at the home at the time Kelly went missing? Where was her live-in boyfriend at the time? Why wasn’t she allowed to use the phone during an emergency? Was that story ever verified by LE? Why didn’t she just go to another neighbor and use their phone?
Statistically speaking, only one percent of abductions are non-familial. I’m not sure what evidence contributed to Kelly being listed as such, but I’m going to assume it was due to Judy’s statements at the time of his entry into NCMEC. However, I’m inclined to believe that he wasn’t abducted at all, and I believe someone knows exactly what happened to him, as well as where he is.
The more I learn the more questions come to mind… I’ll keep digging, and of course post what I learn. In the meantime….
If you have any information about this missing child, please contact the Kentucky State Police at (606) 435-6069.